Elijah Craig 12 Bourbon Review

Distiller: Heaven Hill. ABV: 47%. Age: 12 years. Mashbill: 75% corn, 12% rye, 13% malted barley. Price: $25-35.

It’s with a tear in my eye that I belatedly post this review on one of my standby house pours, the Elijah Craig 12-year-old. The distiller, Heaven Hill, has just confirmed (as of January 2016) what many of us long suspected: it’s discontinuing  the 12-year-old in favor of a no-age-statement version that will be a mix of juice from 8 to 12 years old.

In a world of supply crunches, skyrocketing prices, and vanishing age statements, the EC 12 has stood apart less in terms of taste than in terms of value and consistency. It’s got a classic, straight-down-the-middle Kentucky bourbon profile, warm and familiar as a favorite pair of slippers. The price has been right, the proof is just high enough for some oomph, and it’s right in the sweet spot for bourbon maturation.

Nose of s’mores, vanilla bean, and shoe leather.  Sweet, full, and warming palate with a creamy mouthfeel. A bit of the baking spice of a Wild Turkey, some toasty tobacco notes of a Buffalo Trace, and enough of the sweet corn goodness to hint at an Old Forester Birthday Bourbon. As well-rounded and satisfying as a $25-30 bourbon can be.

I feel like the EC 12 has never quite gotten its due from the enthusiast community, though I have no doubt it’s going to fly off the shelves now that we know it’s on the way out. Heaven Hill assures us the NAS won’t be far off in terms of profile–we’ll bring you a profile just as soon as we can–but we’re still sad to see this one go. Enjoy it while it lasts, friends! -BO

Buy Elijah Craig 12 Bourbon online at Mash + Grape

6 thoughts on “Elijah Craig 12 Bourbon Review”

  1. I haven’t tried the new NAS Small Batch EC yet, but I did discover Henry McKenna 10 year Single Barrel in 2016. It definitely helped ease the pain of losing the Elijah Craig 12.

  2. I found a 1.75 L bottle of the EC 12 last year, so I had a decent quantity which lasted me for a little while. It was certainly one of the best bang-for-your-bucks in all of bourbondom until I came across a couple of 750ml bottles of 12 WL Weller @ $26!

      1. The store manager hid the two bottles of 12 yr Weller in the back and waited for someone to ask if they had any. I also asked him if he had any Thomas H. Handy. He didn’t respond, but he brought out his allotment of two bottles, and then sold those to me at MSRP! Unbelievable. I can only wish that he also had George T. Stagg and William Larue Weller, but that would be way beyond what any mere mortal could hope for. Nevertheless, it was still a great day. I will certainly head back to that shop after the BT antique collection is released again.

        1. Those stories make my day. Glad to know there are still a couple store managers doing the right thing! DEFINITELY worth hitting that place up again.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *